• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Shop
  • Jobs Board
Campaigns & Elections logo

Campaigns & Elections

  • Subscribe
  • My Account
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Articles
    • Industry News
    • CampaignTech
    • Creative
  • Videos
  • Buyer’s Guide
  • Reports
  • Expert Database
  • Events
  • Awards
    • Reed Awards
    • CampaignTech Awards
    • Rising Stars
  • Consultant Directory
  • Become a Member
  • Shop
  • Job Board
  • Subscribe
  • My Account
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn

There’s a New Spotlight on Deceptive Email Tactics, but Some Strategists Say There’s Still a Long Way to Go

One of the progressive strategists leading the charge against deceptive email fundraising practices thinks industry professionals are now closer to consensus on the negative effects of those tactics than ever before.    

In an interview with C&E, Josh Nelson, co-founder of the Juggernaut Project and CEO of Civic Shout, said the past six months have made him hopeful “the tide is finally turning toward ethical email programs that treat supporters with respect.” 

Among the developments pushing strategists in that direction: a spotlight on pre-checked recurring donation boxes in fundraising emails, public concern from credit card companies about a surge in complaints and chargebacks related to those donations, and new scrutiny on bogus donation “match” claims. Earlier this year, the Department of Justice suggested that promoting a donation “match” in a fundraising solicitation that doesn’t operate as described could be seen as “material misrepresentation.”    

Federal and state lawmakers have also jumped in. There’s proposed legislation in Congress that would ban pre-checked recurring donation boxes in emails and similar legislation at the state level in California. 

Subscribe for Industry News Plus the Latest in Campaign Strategy & Tactics

Hidden
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

“So thanks, I think, in no small part to these developments, there’s a growing consensus among practitioners that these tactics are unsustainable and that we’re going to need to regulate our own behavior before somebody else does,” Nelson said. 

And while the collective impact of the recent attention on these tactics has been positive, Nelson said there remains plenty of work to do for practitioners worried about poor email practice. For him and some colleagues on the left, a large part of that work is centered on pushing the biggest players in the space to root out bad actors. 

Following the open letter Nelson and more than 80 other strategists sent to EveryAction in August urging the company to “play a leadership role in pushing the digital fundraising industry in more ethical and sustainable directions,” the plan is to keep up the public pressure on the platforms since “naming and shaming” individual bad actors has little impact.     

“I’ve come to believe that people who are shameless cannot be shamed and that it’s going to be more effective to sort of change the rules of the game,” said Nelson. “That could mean regulators or policymakers stepping in. I think most folks in the industry don’t want to see that out of concern they could take too broad of an approach or an ineffective approach.”

In the full interview above, Nelson also weighs in on the longer-term impacts of deceptive fundraising and the challenge of bringing younger donors into the fundraising ecosystem. 

Share:
FacebookTweetLinkedIn
Filed Under:
Email, Ethics, Fundraising

Primary Sidebar

10/27/2021 10:29 AM EDT
FacebookTweetLinkedIn

C&E Creative Summit 2023 Countdown:

Get Tickets

Most Read

  • Digital Organizing

    How Digital Can Help Thread the Needle in Virginia

  • Sponsored

    Combine Digital Advertising With Direct Mail, The SMART Way

  • Sponsored

    Political Comms Is The Premium Peer-To-Peer Texting Platform

Subscribe for Industry News Plus the Latest in Campaign Strategy & Tactics

Hidden
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Related Articles

See More Ethics Articles
Mail icon on an iphone
Email

War of Words Over Email Deliverability Highlights Partisan Divide on Best Practices

Fundraising

Creative Insights: Engaging Supporters Beyond the Donation Ask

People in line at COVID vaccination facility
COVID

Consulting Firms and Campaigns Weigh COVID Vaccination Requirement

Become a member and get access to exclusive content.

Join Today

Footer

Upcoming Events

  • September 21

    Campaigns & Elections Creative Summit

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

For the latest in campaign strategy & tactics plus industry news and analysis, subscribe for free today.

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Follow us

Follow Campaign and Elections for more daily content.

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • About
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Contact

Copyright © 2023 Political World Communications, LLC

Advertisement

Subscribe for Industry News Plus the Latest in Campaign Strategy & Tactics

Hidden
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.